
So the One & Other project has gone live in Trafalgar Square, and you can watch it on the web as hour after hour for the next four months a stream of the public take their moment in the spotlight.
Or not. Because it's going to get old very quickly. This project will not be about fame or notoriety or even notice for any but a very few. And surely that is right, because we can't be making art by giving a random bunch of people a pedastal to stand on.
So it must be about something else. I don't want to try and work that out here, I haven't really got a clue why Gormley thought this might be a good idea. What I would like to do is point out a few things that sort of are interesting about the project, but which don't seem to be foregrounded.
Firstly, every person is in a timeframe. Every participant is bracketed between two other people--someone is waiting to follow you as you have followed someone else. But you won't get any idea of this from the website, where only the current person's actions seems to be of any interest (sure, you can look at who else is lined up, but you don't get any idea where they fit in the scheme of things).
And of course every individual is locked into a relationship with their own unique hour. But again, you don't get any idea of where they sit in their hour. There is no countdown clock, no sense of time passing. So time based this aint.
There is also an interesting issue around the 24 hour nature of the event. Some people are going to be up there for an hour in the dark hours just before dawn, when only the street sweepers or hardened clubbers are passing. And then there is the weather. Maybe a thunderstorm is ok at 2 in the afternoon, but what about driving cold drizzle at 3 in the morning. What becomes the maschocistic point of it at that hour?
So the project happens in a bigger frame, it needs to be viewable or interpreted as a big project, not as a series of 'Britain's got Talent' live on the fourth plinth.
But so far there is no sign of this happening, no sign of a bigger issue. Just a series of self promoters. Oh well.
[Edit - more thoughts. There is no information on the site about who is up there or what they intended to do or what they thought about what they would do. It would be a no brainer surely to put this info up under the live feed? And how about allowing public comments? Emails/texts/twitters? A rolling response? Moderated? There is no interaction, just watching. Maybe that's the point.]